The accommodation regulations require a lockable cupboard for valuables and passports. Read that clause carefully and it assumes something most Malaysian camps get wrong: that the worker is holding their own passport.

A Clause That Says More Than It Appears To
Regulation 4 of the Employees’ Minimum Standards of Housing, Accommodations and Amenities (Accommodation and Centralized Accommodation) Regulations 2020 lists the basic amenities that may not be shared: a bed, a mattress of at least four inches, a pillow, a blanket, and a cupboard that locks, for valuables and passports.
The cupboard is the item worth stopping on. A locked cupboard for a passport is only a sensible requirement if the passport is in the room. The regulation does not say that in terms, and it imposes no duty about document custody, but the provision it does make only makes sense on that premise. A camp where every passport sits in a site office filing cabinet has furnished a locked cupboard for a document that is not there.
That is a drafting observation rather than a prohibition, and nobody is going to be prosecuted under the accommodation regulations over it. The prohibition lives somewhere else entirely, and it is considerably sharper than anything in Act 446.
The accommodation law gave the worker a lockable cupboard. The law that decides whether the passport may be anywhere else is not an employment law at all.
The Provision That Actually Governs It
Passport custody in Malaysia sits under the Passports Act 1966, and the relevant provision is a criminal one.
Section 12(1)(f) makes it an offence to have in one’s possession, without lawful authority, any passport or internal travel document issued for the use of some person other than oneself. The penalty under section 12(1) is a fine not exceeding ten thousand ringgit, or imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years, or both. Section 12(2) applies the same maximum to contravention of any provision of the Act for which no other penalty is specified.
The offence is possession, not misuse. The provision turns on holding a document issued to someone else without lawful authority. It does not require that anything was done with it, or that the worker objected.
It is not an employment offence. It sits in an immigration and travel-document statute, so it is not resolved at the labour department and does not follow the compliance path an employer is used to.
Five years is the ceiling, not ten thousand ringgit. The fine is modest by comparison with the accommodation offences. The custodial term is not, and it is the part that gets overlooked when this is discussed as a paperwork habit.
The test is lawful authority. That is the statutory language, and it is doing all the work. Commentary commonly identifies visa or permit processing, and a request from the authorities in connection with an investigation, as the situations employers rely on. Those are arguments about lawful authority in particular circumstances, not exemptions written into the Act.
Consent is not addressed. The Act does not provide that the holder’s agreement supplies the authority, so a signed consent form is not the answer it is often treated as.
None of that is a view on how a court would decide a given case, and this article is general information rather than legal advice. The point is narrower and harder to argue with: the provision an employer should be reading on this subject is not in the employment or accommodation legislation, and its exposure is a different order of magnitude from the RM50,000 certification offence.
What Changed in 2023
The second development is recent enough that many camp arrangements predate it.
The Employment (Amendment) Act 2022 came into force on 1 January 2023, together with the Employment (Amendment of First Schedule) Order 2022. Coverage extended from employees earning up to RM2,000 a month plus specified occupations, to all employees under a contract of service whatever their wages, with some provisions not applying to those earning above RM4,000 a month and domestic employees excluded from most of Part XII.
Among the insertions is section 90B, on forced labour. An employer who threatens, deceives or forces an employee to do any activity, service or work, and prevents that employee from proceeding beyond the place or area where such activity, service or work is done, commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding one hundred thousand ringgit, or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both.
Read the elements rather than the headline. The offence couples coercion with confinement, and a document held in an office is not by itself either one. It is, however, the usual mechanism by which both become possible.
That distinction matters and is worth being precise about. Section 90B is not a passport retention offence. It requires coercive conduct together with prevention of movement beyond the place or area of work. Document retention is not named in it. What document retention does is make the second element practically achievable without anyone standing at a gate, which is exactly why it appears as an indicator in forced labour frameworks even where it is not itself the offence.
The coverage change compounds the exposure. A workforce that previously sat outside most of the Employment Act on wage grounds is now inside it, so a provision like this reaches arrangements that were built when it did not.
The Audit Dimension
Alongside the legal position there is a commercial one, and for many operators it bites first.
Retention or withholding of identity documents appears among the recognised indicators of forced labour used in international frameworks, alongside restriction of movement, withholding of wages, excessive overtime, violence, and threats and intimidation. An indicator is not a finding, and a single indicator is not a determination. But an indicator is what an auditor records, and what a client’s own compliance team then has to explain internally.
For a contractor supplying labour into an EPC project, a refinery turnaround or an offshore campaign, the practical consequence arrives through the client rather than through enforcement. A buyer’s social compliance programme will ask where worker passports are held, and the answer is either a one-line statement of practice or a problem that takes months to unwind.
What a Defensible Arrangement Looks Like
The workable position is not complicated, and most of it is already implied by the accommodation standard.
The fourth item is the one that converts good intentions into something an auditor or an investigator can accept. A policy describes what is supposed to happen. A log, kept contemporaneously, is the only thing that shows what did. A camp with an impeccable policy and no record of document movements has nothing to produce when asked.
The second item deserves a caution rather than enthusiasm. Worker-requested safe custody is a reasonable arrangement and widely used, but it does not resolve the statutory question, which turns on lawful authority rather than on agreement. An employer relying on it should understand that it is a practical accommodation and should take proper advice rather than assume a consent form settles the matter.
Why This Sits in an Accommodation Article
Because the camp is where the practice physically lives. The filing cabinet is in the site office, the cupboard is in the room, and the person who holds the key is usually the person in charge of the accommodation. Document custody is treated as an HR matter and administered as a housekeeping one.
That split is why it goes unexamined. Nobody designing the accommodation thought they were making a decision under the Passports Act, and nobody in HR saw the cupboard clause. Our workforce accommodation work treats the two as one question, because the exposure sits at the point where they meet and the evidence that matters is kept at the camp.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it illegal in Malaysia for an employer to hold a worker’s passport?
The Passports Act 1966 section 12(1)(f) makes it an offence to have in one’s possession, without lawful authority, a passport or internal travel document issued for the use of some person other than oneself, with a penalty under section 12(1) of a fine not exceeding RM10,000 or imprisonment not exceeding five years or both. Whether a particular arrangement has lawful authority is a legal question on the facts, and this is general information rather than legal advice.
Does a signed consent form make retention acceptable?
The Act’s test is lawful authority, and it does not provide that the document holder’s agreement supplies it. Consent is not addressed in the provision, so a consent form should not be treated as resolving the statutory position. It may still be relevant to how an arrangement is characterised, which is a matter for proper advice rather than assumption.
What is the forced labour provision in the Employment Act?
Section 90B, inserted by the Employment (Amendment) Act 2022 which came into force on 1 January 2023. An employer who threatens, deceives or forces an employee to do any activity, service or work and prevents that employee from proceeding beyond the place or area where it is done is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding RM100,000 or imprisonment not exceeding two years or both. The offence requires both coercion and prevention of movement; document retention is not named in it.
Why does passport custody come up in a client’s audit?
Because retention or withholding of identity documents is among the recognised indicators of forced labour used in international frameworks, alongside restriction of movement, withholding of wages, excessive overtime, violence and intimidation. An indicator is not a determination, but it is recorded, and a client’s compliance team then has to account for it. A stated policy plus a contemporaneous record of document movements is what closes it quickly.
Sources: Passports Act 1966 (Act 150), section 12(1)(f), making it an offence to have in one’s possession without lawful authority any passport or internal travel document issued for the use of some person other than himself, with the penalty under section 12(1) of a fine not exceeding ten thousand ringgit or imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years or both, and section 12(2) applying the same maximum to contravention of any provision for which no other penalty is specified · Employees’ Minimum Standards of Housing, Accommodations and Amenities (Accommodation and Centralized Accommodation) Regulations 2020, in operation 1 September 2020, regulation 4 on basic amenities not to be shared, requiring a bed, a mattress of at least four inches, a pillow, a blanket and a lockable cupboard for valuables and passports · Employment (Amendment) Act 2022, in force 1 January 2023 together with the Employment (Amendment of First Schedule) Order 2022, extending coverage from employees earning up to RM2,000 a month and specified occupations to all employees under a contract of service regardless of wages, with certain provisions not applying above RM4,000 a month and domestic employees excluded from most of Part XII, and inserting section 90B on forced labour under which an employer who threatens, deceives or forces an employee to do any activity, service or work and prevents that employee from proceeding beyond the place or area where it is done is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding one hundred thousand ringgit or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years or both, as reported in published Malaysian legal commentary on the amendment · Recognised indicators of forced labour used in international frameworks, including retention or withholding of identity documents, restriction of freedom of movement, withholding of wages, excessive overtime, physical or sexual violence, and threats and intimidation. This article is general information and not legal advice.
MarineCraft Journal
Get the next briefing in your inbox
Safety protocols, offshore training, regulation and market analysis, written for Malaysia’s maritime and offshore industry. No sales pitches.
We use your address only to send MarineCraft Journal. Unsubscribe any time. See our Privacy Policy.
