Act 446 lets an employer charge for a bed and sets the ceiling. That is the easy half. The Employment Act then adds a written request and a prior written permission, and an employer who cleared the first gate has usually never heard of the second.

The Permission in the Accommodation Act
Start with the provision most employers know about. Section 24G of the Employees’ Minimum Standards of Housing, Accommodations and Amenities Act 1990 allows an employer, subject to any conditions prescribed by the Minister, to collect from an employee any sum for rent or charge in respect of accommodation provided by the employer or by a centralized accommodation provider under that Part. Subsection (2) states that the sum collected is to be made by deductions from the employee’s wages.
So the Act contemplates charging, and it contemplates recovering the charge through the payroll rather than in cash. What it does not do is fix the amount. That was left to the Minister, and the Minister exercised it.
The Employees’ Minimum Standards of Housing, Accommodations and Amenities (Maximum Rental or Charges for Accommodation) Regulations 2020 were made on 27 August 2020, gazetted on 28 August 2020 as P.U.(A) 249, and came into operation on 1 September 2020, under paragraph 25(2)(ac) of the Act. The instrument is two regulations long. Regulation 2(1) states that the maximum rental or charges for accommodation that may be collected under subsection 24G(1) by an employer from an employee shall be one hundred ringgit. Regulation 2(2) states that any employer who contravenes subregulation (1) commits an offence.
It is a ceiling, not a rate. The regulation sets a maximum, so nothing requires an employer to charge anything. Many do not, and treating the figure as an expected contribution is a misreading.
The text states a figure without stating a period. The operative words are that the maximum shall be one hundred ringgit. No “per month” or equivalent appears in the regulation itself, although it is universally applied as a monthly cap. Anyone building a payroll rule on it should read the gazetted text rather than a summary.
The offence carries no penalty in the instrument. Regulation 2(2) says contravention commits an offence and stops there, so the consequence is found by working back to the Act rather than read off the regulation.
And the estates contrast. Part II of the same Act, which governs estates, carries a section headed no rent or charge to be levied for benefits under the Act. Two regimes again: no charge on an estate, up to a capped charge off one.
Taken alone, this looks like a simple compliance question with a number attached. It is not, because the deduction has to pass through a second statute to reach the payslip.
The Gate Most Employers Have Not Passed
Section 24G says the sum is collected by deduction from wages. Deductions from wages are governed by the Employment Act 1955, and that Act does not treat accommodation as a routine deduction.
Section 24(4) provides that the deductions it lists shall not be made except at the request in writing of the employee and with the prior permission in writing of the Director General. Paragraph (e) of that subsection covers deductions in respect of the rental for accommodation and the cost of services, food and meals provided by the employer to the employee at the employee’s request or under the terms of the employee’s contract of service.
Not the employee’s consent or the regulator’s approval. Both. In writing. Before the deduction is made, not discovered during an inspection afterwards.
Section 24(5) then adds a substantive test rather than a procedural one. The Director General shall not permit any deduction under paragraph 4(e) unless satisfied that the provision of the accommodation, services, food or meals is for the benefit of the employee. That is a judgement about the arrangement, not a rubber stamp on a form, and it means a poor camp is a weaker application than a good one.
Section 24(8) caps the aggregate. The total of any amounts deducted under the section from an employee’s wages in respect of any one month shall not exceed fifty per centum of the wages earned by that employee in that month. For most workforces the accommodation charge alone is nowhere near that, but it is not the only deduction competing for the headroom.
Why the Two Statutes Get Read Separately
The split is organisational. Accommodation compliance sits with whoever manages the camp and the certificate. Payroll sits with finance or HR. The accommodation side reads Act 446, finds a permission and a cap, and instructs payroll to deduct a figure within it. Nobody checks the Employment Act, because from where they are standing the question was already answered.
The result is the common failure: a deduction that is inside the RM100 ceiling, applied uniformly across a workforce, with no individual written request from any employee and no application ever made to the Director General. The amount is right and the authority is missing.
Two further points compound it. The written request is individual, so a clause in a standard contract of service is doing different work from a request from the employee, and paragraph 4(e) refers to both an employee’s request and the terms of the contract of service as the basis on which the accommodation was provided, while subsection (4) separately requires the request in writing for the deduction. And the coverage of the Employment Act changed: since 1 January 2023 it reaches all employees under a contract of service regardless of wages, so a workforce that previously sat outside most of it on wage grounds is now inside.
A deduction can be the right amount, properly recorded, visible on every payslip, and still be unauthorised. The number was never the hard part.
What a Compliant Arrangement Requires
Whether to charge at all is a commercial decision. If the answer is yes, the sequence is not optional.
The first item is worth more thought than it usually gets. The maximum is modest set against the cost of running a certified camp, so the charge rarely moves the economics much. What it does is create an individual consent requirement, a regulatory application, a payroll control and an audit exposure, for a recovery that is small relative to the bed cost. Several operators reach the view that it is not worth the machinery, and that is a defensible commercial answer rather than a concession.
The sixth item matters for a reason beyond compliance. A deduction a worker does not understand becomes a grievance, and a grievance about money taken from wages in connection with housing is precisely the shape that attracts attention in a buyer’s social compliance review, whatever the legal position.
Where This Leaves an Employer
The honest summary is that charging for accommodation in Malaysia is permitted, capped, and procedurally demanding in a way the cap conceals. Act 446 answers whether and how much. The Employment Act answers whether this deduction, from this employee, may be made at all, and its answer depends on two written documents that most arrangements do not have.
Anyone currently deducting should check which of the two gates they passed, and anyone about to start should work the sequence in order rather than from the number backwards. This is general information rather than legal advice, and the wording of each provision should be read as currently in force before a payroll instruction is written against it. Our workforce accommodation work is priced and structured with this in mind, because the question of who bears the bed cost is a contract question before it is a payroll one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an employer charge workers for accommodation in Malaysia?
Yes, within limits. Section 24G of Act 446 allows an employer, subject to conditions prescribed by the Minister, to collect a sum for rent or charge in respect of accommodation provided by the employer or a centralized accommodation provider, with the sum collected by deductions from wages. The Maximum Rental or Charges for Accommodation Regulations 2020, P.U.(A) 249, in operation 1 September 2020, set the maximum at one hundred ringgit, and contravention is an offence.
What does the Employment Act require before the deduction is made?
Both the employee’s request in writing and the prior permission in writing of the Director General. Section 24(4) applies that requirement to the deductions it lists, and paragraph (e) covers rental for accommodation and the cost of services, food and meals provided by the employer at the employee’s request or under the contract of service. Section 24(5) adds that the Director General shall not permit such a deduction unless satisfied the provision is for the employee’s benefit.
Is there a limit on total deductions from wages?
Yes. Section 24(8) of the Employment Act provides that the total of amounts deducted under that section from an employee’s wages in respect of any one month shall not exceed fifty per centum of the wages earned by that employee in that month. An accommodation charge therefore has to be considered alongside every other deduction competing for the same headroom.
Does the cap apply on estates as well?
The charging provision and the cap sit in Part IIIA, which applies to employees employed otherwise than to work in an estate. Part II of the same Act, covering estates, carries a section headed no rent or charge to be levied for benefits under the Act, so the position on an estate differs. As with much of this Act, the regime depends on which Part the workforce falls under.
Sources: Employees’ Minimum Standards of Housing, Accommodations and Amenities Act 1990 (Act 446), section 24G as inserted by the 2019 amendment, subsection (1) allowing an employer, subject to any conditions as may be prescribed by the Minister, to collect from an employee any sum for rent or charge in respect of any accommodation provided by the employer or any centralized accommodation provider under that Part, and subsection (2) providing that the sum collected shall be made by deductions from the wages of the employee, together with section 24F on compliance with minimum standards and section 24I on decent and adequate amenities, and the Part II section headed no rent or charge to be levied for benefits under this Act; wording should be checked against the Act as currently in force · Employees’ Minimum Standards of Housing, Accommodations and Amenities (Maximum Rental or Charges for Accommodation) Regulations 2020, P.U.(A) 249, made 27 August 2020, gazetted 28 August 2020 and in operation 1 September 2020 under paragraph 25(2)(ac) of the Act, regulation 2(1) providing that the maximum rental or charges for accommodation that may be collected under subsection 24G(1) by an employer from an employee shall be one hundred ringgit, with no period stated in the operative text, and regulation 2(2) providing that an employer who contravenes it commits an offence, with no fine or term of imprisonment stated in the instrument · Employment Act 1955 (Act 265), section 24(4) providing that the listed deductions shall not be made except at the request in writing of the employee and with the prior permission in writing of the Director General, paragraph 24(4)(e) covering deductions in respect of the rental for accommodation and the cost of services, food and meals provided by the employer to the employee at the employee’s request or under the terms of the employee’s contract of service, section 24(5) providing that the Director General shall not permit any deduction under paragraph 4(e) unless satisfied that the provision of the accommodation, services, food or meals is for the benefit of the employee, and section 24(8) providing that the total of any amounts deducted under the section in respect of any one month shall not exceed fifty per centum of the wages earned in that month · Employment (Amendment) Act 2022, in force 1 January 2023 with the Employment (Amendment of First Schedule) Order 2022, extending coverage to all employees under a contract of service regardless of wages. This article is general information and not legal advice.
MarineCraft Journal
Get the next briefing in your inbox
Safety protocols, offshore training, regulation and market analysis, written for Malaysia’s maritime and offshore industry. No sales pitches.
We use your address only to send MarineCraft Journal. Unsubscribe any time. See our Privacy Policy.
